“It’s Not Living (If It’s Not With You)” by The 1975: When a Catchy Song Masks a Quiet Desperation

CULTURE WATCH

4/15/20252 min read

There are songs that get stuck in your head, and then there are songs that get stuck in your chest. “It’s Not Living (If It’s Not With You)” by The 1975 manages to do both — and that’s what makes it genius.

At first listen, it’s got all the elements of a bright, synthy pop anthem. You’re probably bopping your head, thinking, "Hey, this is fun." But then you actually listen — and you realize Matty Healy isn’t singing about some starry-eyed romance.

He’s singing about addiction. About dependency. About losing himself in something (or someone) and not knowing who he is without it.

A Glittery Soundtrack for a Messy Mind

This is where The 1975 shines. They take something heavy — like battling heroin addiction — and wrap it in sparkly 80s-inspired pop production. It feels almost wrong to dance to it… and yet, you do.

That’s the trick. The contrast. Because that’s what addiction often looks like from the outside — someone smiling, performing, functioning — while inside, they’re breaking down. And isn’t that relatable in a weird, modern way?

We’ve all had those moments. Putting on a show. Acting like everything’s fine while quietly unraveling.

The Double Life: Matty Healy’s Personal Confession

When Healy sings about “Danny” — the character in the song who struggles with addiction — it’s not exactly subtle. Danny is Matty. It’s a way for him to talk about himself without saying “me.” And that disassociation? That’s part of the story, too.

The lyrics walk this tightrope between heartbreak and craving. There’s a very real sense of loss, but also obsession. You could easily swap out the word “you” for “it,” and the song still makes sense. Because the song isn’t just about a person — it’s about the thing you can’t quit, even when it’s destroying you.

When Love and Addiction Start to Blur

One of the most haunting things about “It’s Not Living…” is how much it mirrors toxic relationships. The chorus — “It’s not living if it’s not with you” — could be something we say to someone we love. But when that love is laced with dependency, it stops being sweet.

It becomes a trap.

Whether you’re addicted to a person, a feeling, a habit — the truth is, you start to believe you need it to survive. That without it, life is dull, meaningless, unbearable. The song doesn’t glorify that; it shows it for what it is: painful, cyclical, all-consuming.

Euphoric Misery, Gen Z Style

This track hits especially hard for a generation that romanticizes sadness without even meaning to. Gen Z is fluent in irony, in dark humor, in turning trauma into art. And “It’s Not Living…” fits right in — it’s tragic, beautiful, and weirdly danceable.

It’s the kind of song you scream-sing at 1 a.m. while cleaning your room or crying on the floor. It feels like having a breakdown in a glitter jacket — everything shiny on the surface, but cracked beneath.

The Party Song That Understands You

The beauty of “It’s Not Living (If It’s Not With You)” is that it’s not trying to fix anything. It’s not telling you to move on, get better, or be okay. It just sits with you in that strange space between craving and regret.

It says:“I know what it’s like to feel like you can’t live without something. I know what it’s like to perform being okay.”

And sometimes, that’s enough. Sometimes, you just need a song that sounds like joy but feels like pain — because that’s what healing often looks like.

So yeah. It is a bop. But it’s also a mirror. And for three and a half minutes, it makes you feel a little less alone in your mess.